Catfish is enjoyed by many across different cultures for its delicate flavor and tender meat. From casual meals to special occasions, it holds a place in various cuisines.
But for Muslims, the question of whether catfish is halal (permissible) under Islamic law remains essential. Islamic dietary laws are grounded in the Quran and hadith, and knowing whether a food is halal or haram is key to adhering to the faith.
In this blog post, we will explore the Islamic perspective on catfish, considering scholarly opinions from the major schools of thought and Quranic guidance. We will also delve into the considerations Muslims should bear in mind when consuming different types of seafood, including catfish.
Is Catfish Halal?
Yes, according to the majority of Islamic scholars, catfish is considered halal. Islamic law, as interpreted by most jurists, permits the consumption of all sea animals. This includes catfish, along with other seafood such as shrimp, lobster, and crabs.
The majority of Sunni scholars, particularly from the Shafi’i, Maliki, and Hanbali schools of thought, uphold this permissibility.
For these scholars, the general rule in Islam is that all seafood is halal unless explicitly forbidden.
Since catfish is not specifically excluded by the Quran or the hadith, it falls under this permissibility. However, as with other aspects of Islamic law, there are nuances across different schools of thought.
Diverging Views Among Islamic Schools
While the majority of Sunni scholars agree on the permissibility of catfish, there are varying opinions in other schools.
The Hanafi school, for example, classifies catfish as makrooh (disliked), meaning it is better to avoid but not sinful to eat.
This is because the Hanafi school has stricter criteria for what constitutes permissible seafood, often limiting it to fish with scales.
On the other hand, scholars within the Shia tradition generally regard catfish as haram (forbidden), as it does not have scales.
Shia scholars often follow the interpretation that only fish with scales are permissible to consume, and catfish falls outside this category. Therefore, depending on the school of thought one follows, the ruling on catfish can differ.
For Muslims following the Shafi’i, Maliki, and Hanbali schools, catfish is completely permissible. For those following the Hanafi or Shia traditions, it may be advised to avoid it due to its classification as makrooh or haram.
READ ALSO: Is Eel Halal? A Complete Guide
The Evidence for Catfish Being Halal
The permissibility of catfish is strongly supported by evidence from both the Quran and hadith. The Quran explicitly permits the consumption of all sea creatures. In Surah Al-Ma’idah, Allah says:
“Lawful to you is game from the sea and its food as provision for you.”
— Surah Al-Ma’idah: 96
This verse broadly includes all sea creatures, reinforcing the view that sea animals are halal for Muslims to consume. Since catfish resides in freshwater but is considered a “fish,” it falls under this general permission.
Additionally, there is a well-known hadith reported by Abu Hurayrah in which the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) said:
“The sea water is pure, and its dead animals are lawful to eat.”
— Related by Abu Dawud, al-Tirmidhi, and al-Nassa’i.
This hadith is often cited to show that Muslims can eat sea animals, even if found dead. This includes all types of fish, such as catfish, further solidifying its permissibility under Islamic law.
Why Catfish Is Halal?
The permissibility of catfish, along with other seafood, aligns with one of Islam’s fundamental principles: everything in this world is considered halal unless explicitly forbidden.
Neither the Quran nor the Prophet (peace be upon him) excluded any type of fish from this general permissibility.
Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) further emphasized that two types of dead animals are halal to consume: sea creatures and locusts.
This means that unlike land animals, which require slaughtering according to specific Islamic guidelines, sea animals do not require this process.
The inclusion of sea animals like catfish in this halal category reflects the ease and comprehensiveness with which Islamic dietary laws apply to seafood.
This also means that the manner in which catfish is caught—whether by Muslims or non-Muslims—does not affect its halal status. So long as it is not harmful or dangerous, catfish remains permissible for consumption.
Practical Considerations: Health and Safety
While catfish is considered halal by the majority of scholars, it is important for Muslims to consider other practical factors. Islamic law emphasizes the importance of preserving human health.
If medical evidence shows that a certain sea animal, including catfish, is harmful to the body, then consuming it becomes haram.
For example, certain species of catfish may carry environmental toxins depending on the water in which they live. Muslims should ensure that the catfish they consume is safe and free from any harmful substances.
Always prioritize health and well-being, as Islam encourages its followers to avoid anything that causes harm, whether on land or sea.
Is Catfish Halal in Sunni Islam?
As previously mentioned, the majority of Sunni Islamic schools (Shafi’i, Hanbali, and Maliki) consider all “sea game” to be halal.
Since catfish falls into this category and does not pose any known dangers, it is considered permissible without the need for slaughtering.
The Hanafi school, while allowing most fish, advises against eating fish that do not have scales, classifying them as makrooh.
Catfish, which lacks scales, is generally not preferred by Hanafi jurists, but it is not entirely forbidden. This more cautious stance is important to note for Muslims who adhere to the Hanafi school of thought.
For Shia Muslims, however, the consumption of catfish is generally regarded as haram, due to its lack of scales. This is consistent with their strict interpretation of halal seafood.
Can Muslims Eat Catfish?
Yes, the majority of scholars agree that Muslims can eat catfish, as it is halal and permissible in Islam. This ruling applies to most Sunni schools of thought, and it is based on clear evidence from the Quran and hadith.
Conclusion
In conclusion, catfish is generally considered halal by most scholars, particularly in the Shafi’i, Maliki, and Hanbali schools. However, Muslims following the Hanafi or Shia traditions may choose to avoid catfish due to its classification as makrooh or haram, respectively.
There is no direct prohibition of catfish in the Quran or hadith, but as always, Muslims are encouraged to seek knowledge and make informed decisions.
If medical science ever proves that consuming catfish is harmful, then its status could change to haram. Ultimately, Islam promotes the consumption of food that is safe and beneficial, whether it comes from the sea or the land.